Because it is the second biggest economy in the world, global economies are linked and China has been threatening many countries around it so many of us in Taiwan, Japan, the Philippines and other ASEAN countries that China threatens and tries to take land or sea from hope they have economic problems that will limit their ability to attack us.
seriously ?
by now nobody should be surprised by data coming out from Chinese government.
they just make up any numbers they want.
in this case, if they report the real unemployment rate, the public will be very disappointed with the government. this may cause unrest, and the communist party wants zero unrest.
the communist party primary objective is to stay in power. and they will do everything in their power to ensure that.
The host in red, with the raised finger, is so aggressively happy, when Chinese people are without jobs. It is probably her job to be biased, but she might add a little more grace and humanity here.
What can you expect? It’s the direct outcome day by day brainwashing by these MSMs with distorted information? But I went to China and clearly know what reality is there. Like any countries right now, it did have economic issues. But overall, it’s in a much better position. These China-collapsing experts have been taking any opportunities to predict Chinese failure for the last 25 years. But Chinese not only came out without issues but also further developed. If you are a Chinese, you can ignore that lady’s bs.
So drama. US and West say China collapsing for the past 20 years 😅. Nothing new. Companies mismanage and close down everyday everywhere. It’s healthy as the fittest survive.
China is having 5% GDP this year and US 1%, 2% and yet some people are saying China is collapsing. If China is collapsing then US is worst than collapsing right? What are these people talking about? Are these people dumb or what?
China is focusing on quality growth and not quantity. China is the only major growth generator of the world now. China has no structural problems while US has structural problems where the government just kicks the can down.
PRC government data are all in Questions. How can you guys interview financial staff to give objective comment? They must be relying on government data for prediction which must be damn wrong 100%. I don’t see any point of listening their views. All are rubbish except he’s working for his own clients
can the host elaborate on what he meant by do “what the West has done…. and pull the trigger on the Bazooka?”
Import low-skilled migrant workers? Pump subsidies into the industries?
Encourage every teen that has just turned 18 and just got ourt of high school to make an Only Fans and show their *bleep* to the world LIKE THEY DO IN AMERICA? HAHHAHA
LMAOOO how can you call yourself a host and expect your interviewee to answer such an asinine question with no context whatsoever….
somebody in the comments said: “maybe u should point finger at xi jinping for such incompetence instead”
truth be told he has done well to provide jobs and bolster the industries of China. It is the US and the West that are constantly trying to bring China down.
For instance, the US has banned the imports of tomatoes and cotton of Xinjiang over allegations of workers abuse with no evidence whatsover. China’s government has done well to mature and develop Xinjiangs’ cotton and tomato industry. So who is destroying it and causing the Uyghur farmers to lose jobs? Well the answer is America and the West who ban tomato and cotton imports from the Xinjiang region! Who caused many workers from Huawei to lose jobs? America and the rest of the world that spin tales of lies against the company.
China is doing so well and really excelent given the fact all of the world is against them and trying to bring them down. That is what you call a “superpower”
This “economist” is funny lack of understanding of basic economics. The modest credit issuance is not the result of monetary policy it is the result of lack of confidence in the market! No-one see the opportunity to borrow money to invest in or has the confidence to borrow money. CNBC has to be careful with what they invite to talk
Of course not. China was closed until deng xioa ping oprned up in 1982. China should do much much better than it does. 14.9 percent is really high for a country with so much left to develop. And, of course, 5 percent GDP growth is not true
Thank you master economist.
There is a consistent measure that OECD (and probably the UN, World Bank etc) uses to measure youth unemployment. It’s people 16 (15)-24 that want a job and have been looking.
Even I’m not from china, the chinese are doing fine base on current market environment. Everyone has food and heat to go thru winter compared to the west
That’s true. China mostly rely on coal burning for heating and electricity and they don’t mind getting gas and oil from Russia.
Also there is no inflation.
It’s fine, at least Chinese government is not making money printing go brrrr like in US or EU. Also it’s pivoting from low-medium tech medium-high tech industry. So it will take time, but patience is needed.
@@dustyrhodes2717 Most of the debt is converted into physical assets such as high-speed rail, airports, and infrastructure. Unlike the United States, everything has become a financial asset with no real impact.
@@megatron6393 China is printing money like crazy and the debt will be borne by the Chinese people, which will lead to economic collapse. The United States is printing money like crazy, and its debts are borne by people around the world. This is the benefit of having economic dominance. Who do you think is worse, China’s bad influence or the bad influence of the United States?
The new youth unemployment data is bullshit. I’ve been investing in China for 20 years, and any veteran can figure out that the Chinese government consistently manipulates their data.
She’s a CCP shill. Even if China’s youth unemployment hit 75%, she’d spin it into good news that China’s young unemployed can take some much needed time off…
Fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me.
We must rapidly increase the pace of decoupling from China. No more investment in China based supply chains. No more work visas. No more Chinese owned brands in the West. This is the only way forward.
@@linmei4188 Are you stupid or just misinformed? Supply chains are moving to Mexico, Vietnam, India, etc. Decoupling from China is happening faster than anyone imagined.
THE CHINESE ECONOMY IN 2023 EXCEEDED AND OUT PERFORMED ALL WESTER ECONOMIES AT 5.2%. CHINESE EXPORT GREW BY 6%. CHINA HAS A DOMEESTIC SAVINGS OF 18 TRILLION DOLLARS. CHINESE TOTAL GOVERNMENT DEBT IS 12.5 TRILLION. THE U.S GDP FOR 2023 IS 2.1% GDP GROWTH 34 TRILLION DEBT, TRADE DEFECITS, AND LESS THAN 1 TRILLION IN DOMESTIC SAVINGS. CHINA CURRENTLY HAS OVER 20 MILLION JOB OPENNG IN MANUFACURING AND THEIR CONSTRUCTION SECTOR. CHINA IS NOT COLLAPSING. ITS A LIE. CHINA REFUSED TO GO INTO DEBT BY STUMULATING THEIR ECONOMY BUY U.S DEBT AND BAAILING OUT THEIR REAL ESTATE SECTOR TO SAVE WESTERN RECKLESS INVESTORS. AND THE WEST IS MAD. SO THEY KEEP LYING.
SO CHINA GROWS AT 5.2% AND THE U.S ECONOMY GREW AT 2.1% AND THE U.S IS DOING GREAT AND CHINA IS COLLAPSING? SO MATH DOES NOT MATTER WHEN IT COMES TO CHINA BAHING?
When western media and academia incessantly warn you about the dire economic situations in China or, worse still, the China Collapse theory, it’s time you should be more worried about what’s happening in the West. Trust me, diverting attention is the best tactic to deal with domestic issues; finding a common external adversary is the best way to win an election. That is of course the basis of western capitalism and democracy.
50 percent are allowed to go to high school, of those, 50 percent are allowed to continue to study at uni. Everything is controlled top down no choice. Vocational and technical schools have very little budget so either you go to uni or you are doomed to a poor life
China also said the Wuhan virus was controllable and containable multiple times during the pandemic. How can you compare numbers reported from a dictatorship vs democratic countries with freedom of the press?
China will switch from labor-intensive industry to high technology, that’s why many countries are moving their factories to Southeast Asia, labor prices are 2 times cheaper than China.
People will just work for longer- the Chinese are pretty practical
This is a good outlook for the future to see Chinese and Indian on the same screen in such a civil way and having an intelligent discussion
Errrrrrr
Hope everyone has a good economy <$
Good attitude
Why people care about China so much. It is developing poor country. Leave it alone.
Because it is the second biggest economy in the world, global economies are linked and China has been threatening many countries around it so many of us in Taiwan, Japan, the Philippines and other ASEAN countries that China threatens and tries to take land or sea from hope they have economic problems that will limit their ability to attack us.
If this is the case, the United States should not suppress Huawei.
@@John-hl2ir you mean Hawaii or Huawei?
seriously ?
by now nobody should be surprised by data coming out from Chinese government.
they just make up any numbers they want.
in this case, if they report the real unemployment rate, the public will be very disappointed with the government. this may cause unrest, and the communist party wants zero unrest.
the communist party primary objective is to stay in power. and they will do everything in their power to ensure that.
Bharat definitely not happy to hear this. Should be at least 25%.
You are Chinese
Poor China stopped publishing youth unemployment number for one year so it can tweak it to a lower number. 😄😄
Please say something about CCP government…
CCP is really good?
😂
The host in red, with the raised finger, is so aggressively happy, when Chinese people are without jobs. It is probably her job to be biased, but she might add a little more grace and humanity here.
India benefits from Chinas suffering. Thats why.
maybe u should point finger at xi jinping for such incompetence instead
@@zo9fg Are you getting my “point” though?
A raised finger is more aggressive in west than in most Asian countries, the host can do better.
What can you expect? It’s the direct outcome day by day brainwashing by these MSMs with distorted information? But I went to China and clearly know what reality is there. Like any countries right now, it did have economic issues. But overall, it’s in a much better position. These China-collapsing experts have been taking any opportunities to predict Chinese failure for the last 25 years. But Chinese not only came out without issues but also further developed. If you are a Chinese, you can ignore that lady’s bs.
So drama. US and West say China collapsing for the past 20 years 😅. Nothing new. Companies mismanage and close down everyday everywhere. It’s healthy as the fittest survive.
China is having 5% GDP this year and US 1%, 2% and yet some people are saying China is collapsing. If China is collapsing then US is worst than collapsing right? What are these people talking about? Are these people dumb or what?
China is focusing on quality growth and not quantity. China is the only major growth generator of the world now. China has no structural problems while US has structural problems where the government just kicks the can down.
PRC government data are all in Questions. How can you guys interview financial staff to give objective comment? They must be relying on government data for prediction which must be damn wrong 100%. I don’t see any point of listening their views. All are rubbish except he’s working for his own clients
Yeah man. Donald trump economy is the best and china is loooooving it
What’s that finger doing ? Is that Indian lecturing her guest?
Unfortunately, China doesn’t have onlyfans that keeps youth employed in the west
omg true.
Lol true
😂 That’s the gist of the issue
Actually, they do. But it’s illegal.
Because Chinese women have a boys body 😂 no ( * Y * ) and a back that keeps going. No butt 😂
can the host elaborate on what he meant by do “what the West has done…. and pull the trigger on the Bazooka?”
Import low-skilled migrant workers? Pump subsidies into the industries?
Encourage every teen that has just turned 18 and just got ourt of high school to make an Only Fans and show their *bleep* to the world LIKE THEY DO IN AMERICA? HAHHAHA
LMAOOO how can you call yourself a host and expect your interviewee to answer such an asinine question with no context whatsoever….
Fake
Liars
Chyna boi^ your butt hurts
somebody in the comments said: “maybe u should point finger at xi jinping for such incompetence instead”
truth be told he has done well to provide jobs and bolster the industries of China. It is the US and the West that are constantly trying to bring China down.
For instance, the US has banned the imports of tomatoes and cotton of Xinjiang over allegations of workers abuse with no evidence whatsover. China’s government has done well to mature and develop Xinjiangs’ cotton and tomato industry. So who is destroying it and causing the Uyghur farmers to lose jobs? Well the answer is America and the West who ban tomato and cotton imports from the Xinjiang region! Who caused many workers from Huawei to lose jobs? America and the rest of the world that spin tales of lies against the company.
China is doing so well and really excelent given the fact all of the world is against them and trying to bring them down. That is what you call a “superpower”
+3 yuan and +200 social credit. thank you WIngTong for your misinformation and lies. Your crying because China is stagnating.
China will not be defeated by difficulties, China will become resilient because of difficulties
@@user-yz4ri4kx9kresilient like japan
the west created china, thats why china has no culture.
china should live like they did 1,000 years ago and stop trying to copy the west.
This “economist” is funny lack of understanding of basic economics. The modest credit issuance is not the result of monetary policy it is the result of lack of confidence in the market! No-one see the opportunity to borrow money to invest in or has the confidence to borrow money. CNBC has to be careful with what they invite to talk
Don’t give her tough questions to answer…she lives and works in China. They might throw her in jail.
Yeah. The West and India can now relax. There is no need to contain China anymore just to stay competitive. China is collapsing on its own.
15% doesn’t sound too bad
Because the number is fake. You can’t trust CCP statistics. Why do you think they stopped reporting it last year?
It’s more like 50%
Chinese coping
The Chinese economy does not require adrenaline shock jab(spell trillions in deficit spending) to produce a +5% growth like how the US does.
Lol what? The chinese stop incentivizing the economy because it got so high as a 1 to 10 ratio of deficit spending to GDP growth 😂
The reason why China is is panic now, sending all their leaders begging is because 5% is not a real number, it’s worse.
China debt to gdp ratio>>> US’ debt to gdp ratio
@@MrKirua21 yep, China is 3x GDP. US is 1.2x
Of course not. China was closed until deng xioa ping oprned up in 1982. China should do much much better than it does. 14.9 percent is really high for a country with so much left to develop. And, of course, 5 percent GDP growth is not true
So many little pinks in this chat. Fuck the ccp and their violent and petty ways.
why would you count students as unemployed? statistics they provided is way more telling, and still very bad
Thank you master economist.
There is a consistent measure that OECD (and probably the UN, World Bank etc) uses to measure youth unemployment. It’s people 16 (15)-24 that want a job and have been looking.
Even I’m not from china, the chinese are doing fine base on current market environment. Everyone has food and heat to go thru winter compared to the west
That’s true. China mostly rely on coal burning for heating and electricity and they don’t mind getting gas and oil from Russia.
Also there is no inflation.
Surprising is close enough to call the “data” a total BS
Yes
Chinese numbers are all faked. The real unemployment is probably higher.
It’s the problem of China’s Productivity that leads to unemployment issues because there’s no Real Growth in their Assets.
It’s fine, at least Chinese government is not making money printing go brrrr like in US or EU. Also it’s pivoting from low-medium tech medium-high tech industry. So it will take time, but patience is needed.
Oh really? Look up their debt. Its 3x the countries GDP 😂 😂 😂
@@dustyrhodes2717 Most of the debt is converted into physical assets such as high-speed rail, airports, and infrastructure. Unlike the United States, everything has become a financial asset with no real impact.
@@dustyrhodes2717USA prints money at of thin air for consumption. The USA GDP is mostly printed dollars and phony accounting
China M2 money supply 2020 was rmb198 trillion, 2023 M2 money supply is rmb292 trillion. Did China went on printing money like crazy?
@@megatron6393 China is printing money like crazy and the debt will be borne by the Chinese people, which will lead to economic collapse. The United States is printing money like crazy, and its debts are borne by people around the world. This is the benefit of having economic dominance. Who do you think is worse, China’s bad influence or the bad influence of the United States?
where have I seen the guest before. this lady from Han Seng bank.
The new youth unemployment data is bullshit. I’ve been investing in China for 20 years, and any veteran can figure out that the Chinese government consistently manipulates their data.
She’s a CCP shill. Even if China’s youth unemployment hit 75%, she’d spin it into good news that China’s young unemployed can take some much needed time off…
Should have waited at least a year. Then, people would forget what the old number was.
What’s is America jobless youth?or British jobless youth?or Indian jobless youth?
It’s surprising that people still trust the data put out by the Chinese gov’t >.<
👍👍‼️🇧🇷🇷🇺🇮🇳🇨🇳🇿🇦➕️👏👏👏
Fool me once, shame on you; fool me twice, shame on me.
We must rapidly increase the pace of decoupling from China. No more investment in China based supply chains. No more work visas. No more Chinese owned brands in the West. This is the only way forward.
India mad cows…??? 🐄🐮😋😜😁🤡🤡🤡
How could points be more stupid than this? relocate the supply chain to which country?
@@linmei4188 Any country other than yours. It is already happening!
@@linmei4188 Are you stupid or just misinformed? Supply chains are moving to Mexico, Vietnam, India, etc. Decoupling from China is happening faster than anyone imagined.
No problem. Just have them work on the military and statecraft stuff!
F Y M !
China is always on the way to collapse! xaxaxaxaxa
THE CHINESE ECONOMY IN 2023 EXCEEDED AND OUT PERFORMED ALL WESTER ECONOMIES AT 5.2%. CHINESE EXPORT GREW BY 6%. CHINA HAS A DOMEESTIC SAVINGS OF 18 TRILLION DOLLARS. CHINESE TOTAL GOVERNMENT DEBT IS 12.5 TRILLION. THE U.S GDP FOR 2023 IS 2.1% GDP GROWTH 34 TRILLION DEBT, TRADE DEFECITS, AND LESS THAN 1 TRILLION IN DOMESTIC SAVINGS. CHINA CURRENTLY HAS OVER 20 MILLION JOB OPENNG IN MANUFACURING AND THEIR CONSTRUCTION SECTOR. CHINA IS NOT COLLAPSING. ITS A LIE. CHINA REFUSED TO GO INTO DEBT BY STUMULATING THEIR ECONOMY BUY U.S DEBT AND BAAILING OUT THEIR REAL ESTATE SECTOR TO SAVE WESTERN RECKLESS INVESTORS. AND THE WEST IS MAD. SO THEY KEEP LYING.
SO CHINA GROWS AT 5.2% AND THE U.S ECONOMY GREW AT 2.1% AND THE U.S IS DOING GREAT AND CHINA IS COLLAPSING? SO MATH DOES NOT MATTER WHEN IT COMES TO CHINA BAHING?
When western media and academia incessantly warn you about the dire economic situations in China or, worse still, the China Collapse theory, it’s time you should be more worried about what’s happening in the West. Trust me, diverting attention is the best tactic to deal with domestic issues; finding a common external adversary is the best way to win an election. That is of course the basis of western capitalism and democracy.
16-24, out of school, has an unemployment of 14%. How many people at this age are out of a school?
50 percent are allowed to go to high school, of those, 50 percent are allowed to continue to study at uni. Everything is controlled top down no choice. Vocational and technical schools have very little budget so either you go to uni or you are doomed to a poor life
CHINESE ARE FAKE
☯️
Youth unemployment?most youth in China are in college. If your country youth needs employment, your county is doomed,😂😂😂😂
25 percent are allowed to go to uni in China. No misinformation please
It’s too bad a government that is so effective at hiding its failures can’t be voted out in a real election.
14 percent youth unemployment rate is common in many developing economies.
China also said the Wuhan virus was controllable and containable multiple times during the pandemic. How can you compare numbers reported from a dictatorship vs democratic countries with freedom of the press?
The Indian host is really impolite. Doesn’t she know what it means to point a finger?
Her parents had never taught her any manners
What’s India youth unemployment and us ?
China doesn’t want to overstimulate with low interest rates and QE like the West.
Yeah, China was open and transparent about covid…
Why to people keep thinking the ccp will play by the wests rules and tell the truth, even if if makes the ccp look really bad?
LOL, look at the faceless wumaos 🐀 in the comments trying to best to spin the fudged CCP data!
China will switch from labor-intensive industry to high technology, that’s why many countries are moving their factories to Southeast Asia, labor prices are 2 times cheaper than China.
there accents are so different
期待が高すぎ