Video shows the moment an altercation broke out on a subway car in Brooklyn before a man was shot was his own gun. WNBC’s Tracie Strahan reports.
» Subscribe to NBC News: https://www.youtube.com/user/NBCNews
NBC News Digital is a collection of innovative and powerful news brands that deliver compelling, diverse and engaging news stories. NBC News Digital features NBCNews.com, MSNBC.com, TODAY.com, Nightly News, Meet the Press, Dateline, and the existing apps and digital extensions of these respective properties. We deliver the best in breaking news, live video coverage, original journalism and segments from your favorite NBC News Shows.
Connect with NBC News Online!
Breaking News Alerts: https://link.nbcnews.com/join/5cj/breaking-news-signup?cid=sm_npd_nn_yt_bn-clip_190621
Visit NBCNews.Com: https://www.nbcnews.com/
Find NBC News on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/NBCNews
Follow NBC News on Twitter: https://twitter.com/NBCNews
Get more of NBC News delivered to your inbox: nbcnews.com/newsletters
#Brooklyn #Subway #Shooting
Diversity is our strength.
Everyone’s sense of security is a false one. What makes you think that can’t happen at any given moment, at any given place? Laws do not keep you safe.
13% never letting us down
Oh please just say you love being racist. Most of the 13% you’re talking about are law abiding citizens and people who are fine. Also I notice you didn’t say anything about any other race that’s mentioned in that video only the “13%” right.
MAGA clansman…..100% predictable.
@@immortalasirpa6006what’s wrong with facts? You are in a state of cognitive dissidents. Google it dummy
🤣🤣🤣outdated information love I’m sure it’s much high minority population now…We’re actually the majority! Ignorance doesn’t have a color💋
@@immortalasirpa6006 Not exactly fool telling it as it is ,we all know it Asians,Hispanics,Russians,Eskimos everyone on the planet,there is something seriously wrong with the homies!
Kitty Genovese
MY BLACK PEOPLE AT IT AGAIN.
WHAT ELSE IS NEW?
deded 😂 with your own piece 😂😂😂😂😂too much
Vote to change the laws
ALL Democratic controlled cities are SH**HOLES.
black people try not to be violent challenge: IMPOSSIBLE!!
Obviously, I am so glad that I am not that type of nationality to be born, praise the LORD!.
Your racism is showing, MAGA.
@@immortalasirpa6006pattern recognition . Your labels mean nothing!
@@AS-kw5hd Your hatred of black people also means nothing, MAGA. It’s just a display of the big empty hole where a human soul should be. Now off you go. To Russia. The white paradise that owns and operates MAGA.
@@immortalasirpa6006 its not racist to acknowledge facts, facts dont care about your fragile feelings. also the fact that you jumped right to assuming maga shows how ignorant and uneducated you truly are. definitely a lib
Weird.. they must’ve left their MAGA hats at home. Right legacy media?
……. Huh? Is this y’all persecution fetish? No one was talking about the right, why’d you have to play the political card.
Well well well,,,,the usual suspects
Well well well… the usual racist bottom feeders with nothing to add.
@@ryanhanson9631you’ll call him racist but you won’t dare say he’s wrong.
Animals. Oh wait, that is an insult to animals.
MAGA. It’s an inclusive term, but offers no insult to animals. It covers all kinds of inhumane behavior.
@@immortalasirpa6006Trump2024🇺🇸
@@immortalasirpa6006 caught you again spreading your ignorance, keep it to your self we don’t want what your selling
@@Incogmagnetofor prison
Since no one was a Trump supporter, this story will disappear quickly
It’s also a nothing story. “2 men fight and one dies in one of the largest cities in the world.” Excuse me if I don’t spit out my drink in surprise.
@@ryanhanson9631 did the other guy die?
I’m sorry, critical condition. So even less of a story.
I’ve seen that he was fatally injured on other reports. I dont know. 🤷♀️@@ryanhanson9631
Wait!! 2nd amendment remember, 2 remember! It sounds like police are more upset with women over the knife then men who pulling out the gun.
Yes, because if he was prosecuted, it would be racist after all 😂😂
It’s like no one is aware that she stabbed him before he pulled out the gun. Don’t people who believe in the 2nd, think self defense is ok? Or does that only apply when it’s against a black person? She literally stabbed him before he pulled out a gun.
Biden really has brought violent crime down!
Back in 2014, there was a fight that broke out inside the subway train and a random guy tried to stopped them. Suddenly, someone took out a knife and slashed the random guy in the face. We were all shocked and trapped in there until we stopped. Stuff like this you never expect to happen to you
This has got to be fake, guns are banned in New York. Unless you are telling me that criminals can still get guns even though they are banned? What?!
noooo. that could never ever happen under the protective watch of NYPD. and super strict gun laws that protect the citizens instead of making being a criminal that much easier.
Anyone can have gun anywhere in this country, just don’t fly. You don’t think there are guns in NY? The most populated city in the country and you don’t think there are guns?
How do you know the guy who pulled out the gun was a criminal? Perhaps he had a gun for protection. Which shows that owning a gun doesn’t make anyone safe.
@@itsascaryworld9788 I’m being sarcastic, banning guns doesn’t make law abiding people safe, it makes them vulnerable.
@@nr7438 if he had a gun in a place where having a gun is against the law, does that not make him a criminal?
Cant believe you showed a video of ther suspects, thats racist.
Here’s why this isn’t a situation to be shocked at for a few reasons.
1. We live in a society where there are a lot more firearms on the street and in people’s hands. So increased incidents are going to happen. Believe it or not NYC subway shootings are pretty rare. It’s normally people fist fighting. Not letting off rounds.
2. The spotlight is on NYC and California but you can Google search for Texas and Florida shooting events. There are shoot outs with Police officers and civilians on the regular. And shootings involving the public is really wild in those places. Everyone has a firearm it seems.
I’m sure Chicago is mostly peaceful too bud.
The state does not matter.
The area and demographic matters.
Take Texas, most of the crime is in democrat areas LIKE EVERY RED STATE with high crime.
Stop trying to manipulate statistics.
@OrtusMallum2075 Do you know how many gun fights happen in rural areas? Come on now. Youre distracted with the non important.
It’s violence happening everywhere
@@el_duderino3432 good point. Violence happening everywhere in cities and in rural areas.
@@YouMustbeJoking852 Nowhere near the amount than democrat areas.
You can easily look up the statistics.
FUC# NewYork, Will NEVER go there
Why is the President not being asked
what can be done about the level of crime on display across America?
Sample Questions:
Are you willing to implement Stop and Frisk in large urban cities? Are you willing to call in the military to help control the goons? Someone needs to be held accountable.
They say crime is less now than under Trump so that means crime is at an all time low…..
Why do anything about it…?
Because violent crime is down by all accounts so it would be a stupid question. We do have more exposure to individual crimes that did not happen in the past but violent crime has been going down pretty steadily for decades. The only big spike in crime for the past 30 years has been under trump.
Violent crime is at an all time low and stop and frisk was unconstitutional (not to mention a failure). Why would you want the president to take away even more rights for literally no reason?
@@wh0dave Not arresting people, not charging people and not prosecuting people does NOT lower crime.
This is how the democrats are manipulating the numbers and providing the illusion that crime is lower.
Violent crime is down. The great lie! Don’t believe your eyes trust in the left and cooperate media. Would we lie to you?
Extremely violent society.
No, not society, demographic.
Everything is about war but we lack control
Democrat cities at its best
Diversity! It’s our greatest strength!
2 big heads, menacing the country with their stupidity
Fun fact: violent crime would go down by about 90% if two particular minority groups were removed from the country.
But wait… I was told Whites are the biggest threat in this country!!!!
The other group were way more violent umm vlad the impaler
@@nerodemp
Brave talk coming from someone whose people are still eating each other.
@@israelgoldberg4293 Great point and one that’s overlooked about Whites who don’t have a history of cannibalism . We can also look to the humane treatment of animals, which is a White people thing. Now we’re told they were cowboys, which of course is a false as black aristocrats in Europe. Blacks will fight dogs to death, they generally have no compassion for animals. Uncle H. Was the first to pass laws regarding the humane treatment of animals. White people things.
imagine being a democrat, voting democrat, living in a democrat city, seeing stuff like this getting worse every day, and thinking republicans are the problem
Is this really national news? A shooting in nyc subways?
I thought national guard was heavy in the subways these days?🤔🤔New York has fallen
1 murder and the city has fallen? Brother, their crime rates are literally the lowest they’ve ever been. Why the hate?
@@ryanhanson9631 i’m not hating…I love New York…if it has not fallen it’s definitely on its knees in a lot of ways…and it is definitely not the mighty big apple it used to be
@@truthbetold8663 in what ways is it on its knees? By every quantifiable measure it’s demonstrably better than its ever been. Spitting provably untrue nonsense to disparage something is the definition of hating.
@@ryanhanson9631 lol…subway for 1…be well
@@truthbetold8663 there were a lot more subway murders in the 70’s… and 80’s… and 90’s… and the 00’s… so how is it fallen?
LIES!!!
Crime is lower than ever…..
The democrats and the White House manipulated numbers so crime is now less than it was under Trump….
32 and 36, wow 👌 all them army’s guards on site, and that stuff still happens . Some folks be having bad days..
Whatever your grievance may be, the gun lobby is there to *arm* it.
They shouldnt go to jail. He was big and the aggressor. There’s clear video on the incident too.
Truth💯💯💯
When did this happen?
But I thought crime was down 🥺
It is, one crime is nothing in a city of 18 million people.
@@ryanhanson9631 as long as you don’t count all the body parts found in Central park 😏
Yes, because one murder will upset that statistic… I get it, you’re a coward. Grow up.
New Yorkers. They’re sophisticated.
Have you ever had the courage to visit New York? Nah, didn’t think so.
“New Yorkers are sophisticated in handling their business”
You get what you vote for
Yep, lower crime rates and an economy back on the rise after 4 years of the highest spending administration in American history.
Shouldn’t the woman who cut him be arrested? I thought protecting others and yourself isn’t tolerated 😅
I mean, they said they were investigating her. And you have no way of knowing her motives. Why contribute at all when all you have to offer is garbage?
HA! Seems your criminal thugs are ignoring your stupid, overstepping gun laws anyway, New York…Idiots.
NBC you forgot to mention their colors. or do you only do that when a white person is involved?
😅 ive seen gun violence and in real life, it never goes the way you think
That’s why I’m not taking the train no more
Kinda crazy that we didn’t have the military in subway systems in the previous administration but yet, people will tell you we’re in a much better position as a country ha
And yet… crime was higher during the previous administration… strange, don’t you think?
@@ryanhanson9631 can’t argue that but one really has to question… If crime rate is lower than it was back then… Why are they installing the national guard to these areas now? Couldn’t be because new York is a “sanctuary” city and got an influx of illegals would it? Oh I’m sorry, we can’t call the illegals illegals. Let me use the right terminology of the lefts standards; “dreamers”. Haha couldn’t be because all these dreamers in New York are surging the crime right? 😂
The irony of saying “New Yorkers are sophisticated”
It’s like looking in the mirror telling yourself you’re beautiful brave and amazing everyday
Who says that? I’ve literally never heard that word to describe New Yorkers. Not even from actual new yorkers… You’ve never been there, have you?
@@ryanhanson9631 did you watch the video?
I lived there for 15 years, I know full well how the people are there. Spoiler: they’re not much better anywhere else.
@ryanhanson9631 The dude in the suit with the police said that. Try watching the video before commenting. ☹️
@@travesty-studios I don’t believe you for a second and the fact that they’re like everyone else was exactly my point.
Sad definition of “sophisticated”.
You misspelled diversity
Shocking
That’s why people don’t help crime victims on the subway, they will get arrested instead of the criminal (if the criminal lives😂) Radical left judge’s and prosecutors have made crime basically legal in democrat shitholes.
New Yorkers sophisticated 🤣
Violence is rampant these days scary incident !
Guessing black dude wasn’t too happy about recent influx of south Americans.
Almost like hateful rhetoric from fear mongers on TV can drive up hate and aggression in a community… where have we seen that before?
@@ryanhanson9631 so stupid. Thinking you can control reality by controlling what people perceive
Go about your business? How about not doing illegal and immoral search and seizures in the subway systems?! There’s criminals on both sides. And leave the woman alone. She was just doing the job that cops never do.
This is what “bail reform” looks like.
And yet fake news keeps trying to tell the public violent crime is down, Democrat politicians defund police, Liberal Judges release violent repeat offenders, Woke DA’s won’t put criminals in jail and ignores the public outcry.
Blame the gun right? No stupid people are the problem. It’s mainly in these garbage leftist cities and states!
Say Man!!! Straight up 💯 self defense. !!! I’m FROM TEXAS!!!!
Always those black folks. Born losers.
I thought the National Guard was going to stop all of that.
I thought diversity was a strength?
I thought white supremacy was the problem???
I thought the national guard was there to prevent this?
The national guard has never stopped anything. Why would you put faith in them now?
…oh yeah nothing to see here.
If you get shot with your own gun, youve failed…
You mean New Yorkers are used to violence 🤦🏻♀️
Looks like them gun laws working real nice huh New York😂
So wait… so they just brought in the National Guard, and it made things WORSE? Yeah, something’s hinky here. Looks like a self fulfilling prophecy, calling the subway dangerous, then people start carrying weapons because they think they need them, then they start shooting and stabbing each other in the tension.
Let me guess.. it was a black guy
This MTA guy doesn’t take the train he talking about getting rid of guns it not legal gun owners fault its people getting ghost guns that a problem i respect my Constitution rights its Protect us from Corrupt government
Mmm, another shooting, and mmm, involving blacks!, now that’s a surprise, according to mainstream media , blacks are peaceful, loving people, heroes, … not fare evading , racist gang banging, rioting, weed smoking, music blasting, intimidating people!😂😂😂😂
🤓 But violent crimes is down everybody
It is, if you think one incident changes that then you don’t know how numbers work.
If only New York had strict gun laws, this couldve been avoided…
Ages no names? New york is stupid. Id never go there. I love danger so its not the guns its the stupidity that exist there that keep the intellectual ones away. NYC is trashed
“Wearing a hat”? Just say “Black dude”!
Take a good look at joe bidens world. Joe bidens world. You and your kids are next.
It’s strange that you can defend with a gun , but not a knife .
I was told once by a former cop that if you defend yourself with a knife you will almost certainly be charged. He said he thinks it’s about the optics and it just looks bad
YES THE BLACK MAN DID PIC A FIGHT. BUT THAT STABBED HIM HE HAD NO KNIFE THAT’S Y HE WENT FOR HIS GUN THAT GIRL STABBED HIM GET THAT GIRL THAT’S Y HE WENT FOR HIS GUN ERIC ADAMS IS FULL OF IT ONCE AGAIN SHE PROVOKED MORE VIOLENCE BY STABBING THIS BLACK MAN IS WHAT WE DOING N NYC GIVING PASSING TO MIGRANTS. GET THIS GIRL
This is why they made the new train cars the way they did because these people were scared
SEE THE WHOLE PICTURE NYC THE NEWS IS NOT SHOWING WHAT REALLY HAPPENED
Sophistication is overwhelming
There are unsophisticated New Yorkers and then there are sophisticated New Yorkers. ( I’m not the latter.)
Move to a white neighborhood.
ATTENTION!!!
Masks cause horrendous pollution that hurts our environment very much. Google :Face mask litter increased almost 9000 percent!
The 34-year-old should be in custody for attempted murder (murder if he dies) and the woman should be charged with attempted murder and/or accomplice to murder if he dies.
1- We do not know what led up to the black man using slurs.
2- The woman was the first to pull and use a lethal weapon.
3- The black man did not pull the gun until AFTER he was stabbed which is a perfectly legal response and is self-defense at that point.
Not even close bud…
@@bobhill4364If someone pulls a knife on you you have a right to defend yourself with a gun. assuming you carry legally. The only thing you are missing is your brains.
You can’t claim self-defense when you are the aggressor…
And let’s not forget it’s all on video.
You can’t claim self-defense either when you’re the one pursuing others with a gun.
It was already announced yesterday that the (latino? Middle-Eastern?) man most likely won’t face any charges but the black man should, including hate crime charges.
Delusional you are
@@bobhill4364 Due to your embarrassing, cowardly, racist comment history your brilliant genius level argument is rejected.
JANDNT
So are you ready to ADDRESS THE ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM YET?
Tyrell and Pablo?
Thanks to Democrats..life seems so safer with them!🙄 Decades of “good living” and “cooler législation” and human rights till disgust!!
So one color hates another color and no white person involved?
Penny is still getting prosecuted.
Wait until the Haitians arrive…it’ll truly be third-world. Thanks Biden!
The aggressor pulled out a gun, and was shot by said gun. What’s the problem?
I would’ve never die to my own gun
If she wouldn’t have stabbed him this would have never escalated into what it is now. And to be honest self defense or not he still shouldn’t have fired multiple rounds on a crowded train. He actually endangered everyone riding that train. The black guy was wrong for picking the fight, and the Spanish guy was wrong for disarming him and than firing into the train car. Once he disarmed him he could have used another alternative to deescalate the situation But, the biggest wrong is the Spanish lady because of she never would have stabbed him. The gun would have never been shown. It’s obvious because he was beating the boy up.
His name was Younece Obuad. He’s Middle Eastern.
Lol, do not pick fights. You can lose everything.
Welcome to NYC 🙈🤪🤪🤪😆😁🤣🤣
Newyork subway system represent every ghetto in America 😂
I left their 17 years ago I’m almost 70 I grew up in New York I’m going to tell you something I don’t know what people have any brains left this is not living do you understand this is no way for no one to live yet you’re saying oh I got to do it no you don’t and yet you talk about Russia another countries they don’t do this because they don’t tolerate none of that play you can ride your motorcycle you can ride your car you can go fishing for free you can do it but you can’t cause damage to society over there
Someone get that Zulu Queen off the train!! 😂
Shut down the MTA cause to them it is all about money and never the people on that train. Where was the help? National Guard ? NYPD? They are not on the train with us. If MTA can’t protect the loves of the people on the train, then shut it down. It is the same for all other businesses, so MTA should not get any special privileges.
Diversity is bad
That couple cursed themselves. Thry ar now marked. NY is the worst place to be marked as a violent being. They better get out of the country
Nah, Joy Reid says it was self defense. Turn off your brain and ignore everything you just saw.
Still have faith in the democrats running this circus?