Andrew Collier with Orient Capital Research discusses one China’s largest ever securities merger, and also addresses the lack of stimulus in the Chinese economy.
CNBC and most of Western media are blind. Why is 5% growth so horrific for China ? It’s a lot better than the US and much much better than the EU. The issue for Western economies is that the Chinese are spending sensibly on local goods and eV, and for going foreign brands like Chevy, VW, VL, Gucci, Rolex … Imports are losing share to the local competition. In other words the only time when it’s “normal” for foreign brands is when the Chinese enjoy a housing bubble, throw money at luxury and brands like no tomorrow instead buying sensibly what is good enough and they really need. This is unsustainable greed. The Chinese consumer market cannot sustain over 50% of global consumer brands’ profits forever. So Germany/VW is doing badly in China but it’s not because Chinese consumers are not buying, nor is China’s economy collapsing. They are buying BYD’s, NIO, and Zeekr etc all better tech and value than VW.
From the Xi’s and ordinary Chineses’ POV there is absolutely nothing wrong with a stead 5% growth, with a healthy trade surplus, and zero inflation which is not deflation at all.
Yeah right! In 2012 when xi came to power that growth was 8-9 sometimes even 10+%! If your objective is to eradicate poverty and increase “common prosperity” surely halving your growth isn’t the right way to go
@@johnmonk3381The US economy grew 2% at the US$17 trillion mark. China is growing at 4.5% at 17 trillion mark which is pretty gòod. No economy can grow at 8% at 17 trillion i.e. add US$1.36 trillion per year. The US economy has been growing average 2% to 2.5% for many years.
Why would a trade surplus mean a good domestic economy?? A surplus only means the country exported more than it imported and nothing else about domestic consumption, nothing about the banking or real estate sectors both of which are in horrible shape in china
@@johnmonk3381horrible state is what your media told you… You will never know China’s real economic growth! China won’t tell you or reveal! No matter what China’s data is your media will say it’s fake 😂
The US is doing great with USD 35.1 Trillion of debts and increasing in huge proportion every day. The US does not manufacture almost anything that the world really need, yet still doing great. Inflation in the US is hitting all time high, yet still doing great. Everything bad becomes great just because they are the US. 😂😂😂😂
China is the World’s sole manufacturing powerhouse producing and supplying almost everything if not everything that the world needs at affordable prices with HUGE trade surplus of USD 823 Billions every year and climbing even higher, yet still bad. China is partnering and working very close with almost the entire world, yet still bad. Inflation in China is quite low, yet still not good.
Even 10 years old kids can differentiate it. Their conclusion is everything that has China is very bad and everything about the US is super great. 😂😂😂😂
If your growth rate has been halved, tons of real estate companies going bankrupt and billionaires are disappearing or leaving in droves, that still isn’t bad?? When “lying flat” becomes the main theme of the mainstream youth who feel unmotivated to work because what’s the point, everything is going to shit, that ISN’T BAD??
@@johnmonk3381
even with growth rate being halved, China still has the growth rate the G7 will kill for, LOL. What matter isn’t high growth, but quality growth. Real estate problem is something that bound to happen when you pop the bubble, and it is better to pop it now than later, and it will take years to solve it, anyone who tell you otherwise is lying or dumb. I couldn’t give a crap about corrupt billionaires fate. Lying flat is how the youth protesting overwork. If they can do that, that means they still have strength to leverage. Employers will just have to negotiate better deal if they need workers.
“President Xi is not being told how badly China’s economy is doing”‘… And the Economic minister of China has told you everything about China’s economy… My god…😂😂😂
Well, I am glad we tell our presidents how well our evonomy is doing😂😂 Where are we, 35 trillion? In the meantime, exports for China rose 8.7% in August😮
@@phillip76 US fiscal imbalance has nothing to do with peak or no peak. US is a high tech dynamic economy while China is stuck in the middle income trap. Rule of law and entrepreneurship is what is needed to take China to the next level but that is impossible under Xi/CCP
What does the U.S. really produce other than the dollar? It imports everything, so if it can ‘t import, then logically it becomes a third world country.
Your “high tech dynamics” doesn’t make much sense either. The U.S. is uncompetitive in any type of manufacturing, and it is uncompetitive in everything. Most businesses would rather go to India for services work, and China or Mexico for manufecturing, and then import back to the states.
You might argue U.S is still good with Research and development? Most R&D are done by Chinese and Indians, and foreigners. If you look at all the science competitions, it is dominated by Chinese names. What is so special about companies really needing America to develope, and research their products. Chinese are simple smarter, better quality, and most importantly cheaper.
U.S. is always third world. It is maintained by the empire, forcing others to use the dollar. There is really nothing of an economy. In fact, real wage pretty must stagnate for 50 years for the botton 80% of Americans. Without Chinese goods, Americans are just going to be poorer.
It is very fair to say U.S. is pass it peak. If wanna put a date, it would around the early 1970s. China is much more better. Its people are nicer, more hard working, smarter, and more willing to start a business and tech driven. They are simply better humans.
@@phillip76 simply better humans?! LOL good one tiktok chinabot. You are clearly not aware of how development economics work. A farmer makes stuff too, it does not mean an agricultural economy is superior to a service economy. The problem for CCP china with their export oriented economy is that it is relatively easy to buy from someone else. Not overnight, but most companies are shifting sourcing away from china to other manufacturing nations.
And by the way, if the communist chinese are such grand people, how come most of their neighbours habe poor relations with them? Japan, SK, India, Phillipines etc. Only NK is “friendly” because they are a chinese satrapy.
CCP china has run its course, I hope for the sake of the Chinese people they will get better leadership than the pumpous idiot Xi the “wolf warrior” poobear
china’s economy is peaking or not is none of EU and America’s problem. In fact , none of them has the capacity to help china in any way. in fact, they cant even help themselve. they are only good at playing with thr interest rate and money ease. that isthe only thing china government doesnt do.
It is funny how these economic liberals go about saying governmen] is bad, but now expect the government to save them. It is nonsense. China can ‘t constantly inflate its economy to safe western businesses. China don ‘t need more houses, more roads, but China does need to protect itself from U.S. aggression.
State resources is now being channeled to create a tech wall from the effects of the U.S tech blockade.
LMAO. I’m so glad I moderated my exposure to the Shanghai CSI 300 these past handful years . What a pile of 💩!! Completely left in the dust.
I “knew” better, but FOMO got the best of me. It should have been zero dollars.
you got a white guy on your show, all the sudden he becomes the chinese expert. he knows everything what has gone wrong in china and provides zero or idiotic solution even the west does not practice themselve.
America has not been told , about how bad the suffering of american people
| I Spent a Day in LA’s Most Dangerous Hood |
| Zombie-like woman found convulsing near abandoned house |
| Open Air💉Market • Ep 38 | Los Angeles, California [4K] 🇺🇸 |
| Pizza 🍕& Rodents 🐀 (Ft. Rebecca Olsen) • Ep 43 | Los Angeles, California |
figures of gun-related deaths in the U.S. over the last 6 years (Pew Research Center)
39,740 in 2018 39,707 in 2019 45,222 in 2020 48,830 in 2021 40,125 in 2022 42,888 in 2023
united states can do nothing to stop American Zombies from growing
| Streets of Philadelphia, Kensington Ave Documentary | youtube
| Inside Philadelphia’s ‘Zombie City’ The Real-Life Horror of Kensington | youtube
If you are that smart, can you tell your president how to balance the USA annual budget and repay the US$36 trillion debt! This is arrogance and ignorance to the maximum. If fact, if most of the American elite are operating at this kind of level, we are quite sure that USA is really in a decline!
Opine, PRChina’s economic decline has reached a stage of no return back, it is now at thoroughly rotten state of affairs, that nobody among Chairman Xi’s top advisors nor his close circle of selected Lieutenants would dare to inform him, lest be punished severely. Chairman Xi is so oblivious of the People’s Bank of China’s lack of monies, that he even promised/pledged to provide additional aids of some USD50 Billion over the next 3-years, during last week in Beijing at the Forum on China-Africa Cooperation held at the Great Hall of the People on Sept. 5, 2024.
Has this guy been to China?
On the contrary he knew that quite a while
Anglo propaganda.
China will continue to keep these western “experts” in the dark.
Fake news… Care for America, don’t worry about China.
He knows every thing what Xi is being told, that cracks me up. 😂
He is Superman …. 😂😂😂😂
He thinks he knows more. cute.
Hope he watches this interview before it’s too late.
That’s his analysis based on Chinese trade, economic and employment facts and figures. Are you such a massive duffer to not interpret that?
CNBC and most of Western media are blind. Why is 5% growth so horrific for China ? It’s a lot better than the US and much much better than the EU. The issue for Western economies is that the Chinese are spending sensibly on local goods and eV, and for going foreign brands like Chevy, VW, VL, Gucci, Rolex … Imports are losing share to the local competition. In other words the only time when it’s “normal” for foreign brands is when the Chinese enjoy a housing bubble, throw money at luxury and brands like no tomorrow instead buying sensibly what is good enough and they really need. This is unsustainable greed. The Chinese consumer market cannot sustain over 50% of global consumer brands’ profits forever. So Germany/VW is doing badly in China but it’s not because Chinese consumers are not buying, nor is China’s economy collapsing. They are buying BYD’s, NIO, and Zeekr etc all better tech and value than VW.
From the Xi’s and ordinary Chineses’ POV there is absolutely nothing wrong with a stead 5% growth, with a healthy trade surplus, and zero inflation which is not deflation at all.
Chinas real growth is 2%. Very low for a developing country
@@GowthamNatarajanAInever trust this fella’s fakes
Yeah right! In 2012 when xi came to power that growth was 8-9 sometimes even 10+%! If your objective is to eradicate poverty and increase “common prosperity” surely halving your growth isn’t the right way to go
That is completely, right. All this screaming about China no consuming is so self-serving.
@@johnmonk3381The US economy grew 2% at the US$17 trillion mark. China is growing at 4.5% at 17 trillion mark which is pretty gòod. No economy can grow at 8% at 17 trillion i.e. add US$1.36 trillion per year. The US economy has been growing average 2% to 2.5% for many years.
With $800 billion trade surplus every year, how can you say China’s economy is bad ??????
When someone is so jealous to see the China 800 billion trade surplus every year, he will not hesitate to say anything negative about China.
Why would a trade surplus mean a good domestic economy?? A surplus only means the country exported more than it imported and nothing else about domestic consumption, nothing about the banking or real estate sectors both of which are in horrible shape in china
@@johnmonk3381look at China nothing like what you hope for 😂
@@johnmonk3381horrible state is what your media told you… You will never know China’s real economic growth! China won’t tell you or reveal! No matter what China’s data is your media will say it’s fake 😂
@@WorldSpaceRace why would u know what kind of hope i have for china! 😂
” President Biden is ‘not being told’ how badly USA’s economy is doing:” Lol, Mr. Andrew Collier!!!!!
The US is doing great with USD 35.1 Trillion of debts and increasing in huge proportion every day. The US does not manufacture almost anything that the world really need, yet still doing great. Inflation in the US is hitting all time high, yet still doing great. Everything bad becomes great just because they are the US. 😂😂😂😂
China is the World’s sole manufacturing powerhouse producing and supplying almost everything if not everything that the world needs at affordable prices with HUGE trade surplus of USD 823 Billions every year and climbing even higher, yet still bad. China is partnering and working very close with almost the entire world, yet still bad. Inflation in China is quite low, yet still not good.
Even 10 years old kids can differentiate it. Their conclusion is everything that has China is very bad and everything about the US is super great. 😂😂😂😂
How do you know Andrew?
Biden isn’t told how many homeless people are sleeping on the streets of US of A every night. That’s why he said US is doing well under his care.
Someone should be telling this man is not particularly bright
The people who make such a lame statement is delusional and living in their small movie dream bubble.
China is doing quite well so those critics can spend more time to focus on the US and western crisis and issues instead.
President Xi is many times more aware than him and the so-called US experts. 😂😂😂
Chinese GDP is still growing, they also don’t have hyper inflation problem, what is bad?
If your growth rate has been halved, tons of real estate companies going bankrupt and billionaires are disappearing or leaving in droves, that still isn’t bad?? When “lying flat” becomes the main theme of the mainstream youth who feel unmotivated to work because what’s the point, everything is going to shit, that ISN’T BAD??
@@johnmonk3381
even with growth rate being halved, China still has the growth rate the G7 will kill for, LOL. What matter isn’t high growth, but quality growth. Real estate problem is something that bound to happen when you pop the bubble, and it is better to pop it now than later, and it will take years to solve it, anyone who tell you otherwise is lying or dumb. I couldn’t give a crap about corrupt billionaires fate. Lying flat is how the youth protesting overwork. If they can do that, that means they still have strength to leverage. Employers will just have to negotiate better deal if they need workers.
CCP wumao spotted
“President Xi is not being told how badly China’s economy is doing”‘… And the Economic minister of China has told you everything about China’s economy… My god…😂😂😂
Are you sure that Xi is not being told how badly China’s economy is? Western MSMs tell him every day 24/7. You’re literally telling him right now 😂
@@patiencesmith7782 They can’t and don’t have the privilege to tell him but they are shouting and boasting all over YouTube by themselves … 😂 😂 😂
You’re dead right!!
This pleb has been reading what Gordon Chang’s failed predictions..😂😂
Well, I am glad we tell our presidents how well our evonomy is doing😂😂 Where are we, 35 trillion? In the meantime, exports for China rose 8.7% in August😮
China is not peaking, it has already peaked.
U.S. peaked too, and it is falling. The only reason it is not a third world country is because China still accepts the dollar.
@@phillip76 US fiscal imbalance has nothing to do with peak or no peak. US is a high tech dynamic economy while China is stuck in the middle income trap. Rule of law and entrepreneurship is what is needed to take China to the next level but that is impossible under Xi/CCP
@@MultiMenvafan
What does the U.S. really produce other than the dollar? It imports everything, so if it can ‘t import, then logically it becomes a third world country.
Your “high tech dynamics” doesn’t make much sense either. The U.S. is uncompetitive in any type of manufacturing, and it is uncompetitive in everything. Most businesses would rather go to India for services work, and China or Mexico for manufecturing, and then import back to the states.
You might argue U.S is still good with Research and development? Most R&D are done by Chinese and Indians, and foreigners. If you look at all the science competitions, it is dominated by Chinese names. What is so special about companies really needing America to develope, and research their products. Chinese are simple smarter, better quality, and most importantly cheaper.
U.S. is always third world. It is maintained by the empire, forcing others to use the dollar. There is really nothing of an economy. In fact, real wage pretty must stagnate for 50 years for the botton 80% of Americans. Without Chinese goods, Americans are just going to be poorer.
It is very fair to say U.S. is pass it peak. If wanna put a date, it would around the early 1970s. China is much more better. Its people are nicer, more hard working, smarter, and more willing to start a business and tech driven. They are simply better humans.
@@phillip76 simply better humans?! LOL good one tiktok chinabot. You are clearly not aware of how development economics work. A farmer makes stuff too, it does not mean an agricultural economy is superior to a service economy. The problem for CCP china with their export oriented economy is that it is relatively easy to buy from someone else. Not overnight, but most companies are shifting sourcing away from china to other manufacturing nations.
And by the way, if the communist chinese are such grand people, how come most of their neighbours habe poor relations with them? Japan, SK, India, Phillipines etc. Only NK is “friendly” because they are a chinese satrapy.
CCP china has run its course, I hope for the sake of the Chinese people they will get better leadership than the pumpous idiot Xi the “wolf warrior” poobear
china’s economy is peaking or not is none of EU and America’s problem. In fact , none of them has the capacity to help china in any way. in fact, they cant even help themselve. they are only good at playing with thr interest rate and money ease. that isthe only thing china government doesnt do.
Load of Crap
It is funny how these economic liberals go about saying governmen] is bad, but now expect the government to save them. It is nonsense. China can ‘t constantly inflate its economy to safe western businesses. China don ‘t need more houses, more roads, but China does need to protect itself from U.S. aggression.
State resources is now being channeled to create a tech wall from the effects of the U.S tech blockade.
Hey Xi Jing Ping, watch CMBC.
Poor guy
Good, China needs to bring down its housing price so their population can stabilize
is this guy a Chinese economy expert?
各行各业都卷，供过于求，价格越来越低，中国政府还在投资刺激生产呢，唉😮💨
Their Plan is to push the Manufacturing more and more
LMAO. I’m so glad I moderated my exposure to the Shanghai CSI 300 these past handful years . What a pile of 💩!! Completely left in the dust.
I “knew” better, but FOMO got the best of me. It should have been zero dollars.
US markets ftmfw.
This guy must think China is also run by a leader who has dementia and has no idea of the economy.
“not being told”, eh…? lol
you have to say “China is bad”. Otherwise, no one interviews you.
you got a white guy on your show, all the sudden he becomes the chinese expert. he knows everything what has gone wrong in china and provides zero or idiotic solution even the west does not practice themselve.
Gordon Chang : China is collapsing.
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
America has not been told , about how bad the suffering of american people
| I Spent a Day in LA’s Most Dangerous Hood |
| Zombie-like woman found convulsing near abandoned house |
| Open Air💉Market • Ep 38 | Los Angeles, California [4K] 🇺🇸 |
| Pizza 🍕& Rodents 🐀 (Ft. Rebecca Olsen) • Ep 43 | Los Angeles, California |
figures of gun-related deaths in the U.S. over the last 6 years (Pew Research Center)
39,740 in 2018 39,707 in 2019 45,222 in 2020 48,830 in 2021 40,125 in 2022 42,888 in 2023
” U.S. Reaches 600+ Mass Shootings For Third Year In A Row ” – MSNBC News 2024
‘ US national debt just surpassed another milestone: $35 trillion.
paying Almost 1 Trillion Dollars as interest to annually … ‘
united states can do nothing to stop American Zombies from growing
| Streets of Philadelphia, Kensington Ave Documentary | youtube
| Inside Philadelphia’s ‘Zombie City’ The Real-Life Horror of Kensington | youtube
“If you tell a lie big enough and keep repeating it, people will eventually come to believe it”
– Joseph Goebbels
Propaganda machine😂😂😂
Fake news… President Xi is in complete control
If you are that smart, can you tell your president how to balance the USA annual budget and repay the US$36 trillion debt! This is arrogance and ignorance to the maximum. If fact, if most of the American elite are operating at this kind of level, we are quite sure that USA is really in a decline!
Opine, PRChina’s economic decline has reached a stage of no return back, it is now at thoroughly rotten state of affairs, that nobody among Chairman Xi’s top advisors nor his close circle of selected Lieutenants would dare to inform him, lest be punished severely. Chairman Xi is so oblivious of the People’s Bank of China’s lack of monies, that he even promised/pledged to provide additional aids of some USD50 Billion over the next 3-years, during last week in Beijing at the Forum on China-Africa Cooperation held at the Great Hall of the People on Sept. 5, 2024.
They wouldn’t understand it if they were told.
It is the Americans who are not told by their government how bad the US economy is doing.
Right … US 35 Trillion in debt …
China’s economy is doing a sight better than both the US and EU combined.
Don’t bring him bad news
Lots of 50-cent CCP wumaos.