While Biden talked about Israel withdrawing from more populated areas of Gaza, Abdullah al-Arian, professor of history at Georgetown University, Qatar, says it isn’t known if there is an acknowledgement from the US that Israel will remain occupying parts of Gaza even after the ceasefire is reached.
“I think this is a major sticking point and one that Palestinians have continuously rejected that any part of Gaza should remain occupied,” he told Al Jazeera.
“There’s a major contradiction here and the fact that both the US and the Israeli side have said on the one hand, that they don’t want a future in Gaza in which Hamas has any kind of political role left.
“At the same time, this is an agreement that would have to be reached through negotiations with Hamas, so, how do you do that? How do you eliminate them as a political force and at the same time reach a negotiated solution that is agreed upon by all parties?”
Subscribe to our channel: http://bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow us on Twitter: https://twitter.com/AJEnglish
Find us on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/aljazeera
Check our website: http://www.aljazeera.com/
Check out our Instagram page: https://www.instagram.com/aljazeeraenglish/
Download AJE Mobile App: https://aje.io/AJEMobile
He claimed he saw 40 beheaded babies, that’s a lie, the White House said their is no video of 40 beheaded babies
They speak of peace whn plan to attck.
Biden trying very hard to reward bad behavior.
Of course this is a trap to obtain all their hostages then afterwards the genocide continues…
US and Israel are not serious in deals they are gaining more time to kill as many human. All deals presented by US was unaccptable for Israel. Situation is worsening day by day and ICJ just issue statement only and no concrete suppotive act.
American government is not to be trusted.
Everything the liberal world order agenda pushers is contradicting, evil and only shows how desperate they are to clinging onto power to push the UN 2030 goals. War freats change hence why they are eager to provoke russia into nuclear confrontation
I might feel sympathy for the ordinary Palestinains, and contempt for Netanyahu but I whish Hamas had the decency to shut up!
I would like, in these interview they were remembered HOW this war started, that they they knew what was coming over the Civilian population, that they hid behind those Civilians.
Still, they have the guts to claim some kind of “authority” speaking about the sufferings they are the main cause of, as if it was just someone else fault.
If the Palestinians had any good sense, they would be putting their heads together and working to construct an alternative to Hamas.
Seems like they have no interest.
.
October 7th was horrable..notice similarites of destruction of cars in Gaza to cars at the festivals that day.
Biden has to insist on a permanent ceasefire otherwise the genocide will continue. Netanyahu wants to continue the ethnic cleansing and land grabbing to annihilate Palestinians
The occupation economic plan for Gaza.
Real Estate. Google, Gaza 2035.
Produce oil and gas
Build the Ben Gurion canal and port.
Google, Gaza oil and gas
Gaza must be no place for hamas that Israel will accept
Hamas should never trust USA.
Free free Palestine
Biden 0:47 be trusted. Up coming elections in November is what Biden is now working up to and now changed his tone.
💪🇮🇱🇺🇲💪🇮🇱🇺🇲💪🇮🇱🇺🇲
There is no phase 2, Negotiations mean no agreement by Israel. This has been proven since 1917 !
This is called “election ceasefire “.😁
ZIONIST LEADER NOT WANTING TO STOP WAR TO KEEP HIMSELF OUT OF PRISON DUE TO FRAUD CASES AGAINST HIM
Palestine has to be free specially after this heinous genocide. USA alone should not get in there to rebuild the nation but Russia and other countries should also participate so that USA cannot take control of that land to rule the middle east.
Can’t trust a word from zoinist
Do not put your safety and security in the hands of the hypocrites. Happy to for common cause for peace
90% of Palestinians have been genetically and anthropologically proven to descend from Jews who converted to Christianity and Islam. They never left the land. Palestinians have been 96% of the deaths and Israelis only 4% for 80 years.
Without philidalpia border will be no casefire….after control on philidalpia border Americanans want casefire……no casefire
How BIG of an absolute embarrassment is this Isr govt? They said they will defeat Hamas, “complete and total victory”, the words of their crime minister.
8mths later, homes destroyed, 40k civillians dead, only 3 hostages “rescued” (they kill their own hostages), get charged with an arrest warrant for war crimes, murder UN staff, WCK workers. doctors, patients, everyone.. And yet still cannot defeat Hamas with superior US sponsored weapons..
And still have corruption charges back at home.. Wow.. Only Geno Joe will bend over backwards to this pathological liar. The whole world can obviously see he is an aboslute joke of a PM.
Hamas has said from DAY 1, END the OCCUPATION, stop the ILLEGAL SETTLERS, leave Gaza for good and recognise PALESTINE as a state = all hostages will be released safely.
What did the war criminals do? “We will destroy Gaza so everyone will see what happens to them if they go against us too. Gaza will be an example”.
And STILL no word of an END TO THE OCCUPATION, Palestine state. 🙄🙄🙄
The leaders are liars and cheaters
King Salman should be careful unless Palestine is free Country.
Read the Geneva Conventions, the Olso accords, camp David Accords. Read the Rome Statute that lists out the 11 crimes against humanity and maybe 🤔 ask yourself if these crimes are happening.
Murder;
Extermination [including “the intentional infliction of conditions of life, inter alia the deprivation of access to food and medicine, calculated to bring about the destruction of part of a population”];
Enslavement;
Deportation or forcible transfer of population;
Imprisonment or other severe deprivation of physical liberty in violation of fundamental rules of international law;
Torture;
Rape, sexual slavery, enforced prostitution, forced pregnancy, enforced sterilization, or any other form of sexual violence of comparable gravity
Persecution against any identifiable group or collectivity on political, racial, national, ethnic, cultural, religious, gender as defined in paragraph 3, or other grounds that are universally recognized as impermissible under international law, in connection with any act referred to in this paragraph or any crime within the jurisdiction of the Court;
Enforced disappearance of persons;
The crime of apartheid;
Other inhumane acts of a similar character intentionally causing great suffering, or serious injury to body or to mental or physical health.
Who would trust an agreement by the Devils.
Indeed, the Devil is in the details of this agreement.
Can not be trusted.
Theres a Georgetown in Qatar?
Give the Palestinians their land back.
USA solutions cannot work because they are spineless. USA is trying to solve the problem which involves lives and deaths of nations by USA doing nothing but like going into quest to find some trick words and some situation solving options which could just by words solve everything and USA needing to do nothing in action, Proposals from USA are spineless because what USA tries to do is it keeps serving Israelis and so it does nothing on ground or in action to standup against the genocide which it itself is part of and it tries to find some kind of trick and some kind of potion which could be accepted by Israelis and Hamas while none of the real issue is addressed and it is presented only with intent to help USA, Egypt, Qatar, Jordan etc. to get a relief from the situation because of their complicity in genocide and these countries want to be seen as done something by actually doing nothing on ground against Israelis who are killing babies, children , women and helpless men and solution is never intended for issues but is intended for making the position of USA good by USA needing to do nothing . As USA is presenting a solution so has USA have made clear to Israelis that land grab is not possible and they should forget Gaza and have Israelis accepted it when whole Israeli nation has been till now dancing and singing hand in hand for genocide for land grab ? Probably not because adamant Israelis are this seems improbable. USA needs to standup to correct its own wrong in genocide against Israelis to stop them else this drama as if ruby cube solving to stop a war will make USA more incompetent than it is seeming now and it will not work
We don’t need these leaders from America to Israel we think their time is over no more insufficient leaders from America to Israel😂
Biden is a liar.
The proposal is BS! And Biden, Netanyahu needs to be in jail for war crimes.
Hamas 😂😂😂there not accepting because they know it’s a trap😅😅😅
All hot air and double dealing….. Unless they allow the Palestinians to have their own land not occupied governed or overlooked by Israel the protests will get worse, to the point of civil disobedience even. And even if that is achieved Israel and America get no free pass, they must express deep humility and remorse for their murderous pact…..
Benjamin Netanyahu real name benzion mileikowsky check it out.
Israel’s time will come and it will be worse than this.
Biden is being hurt badly in the presidential election, he needs to show he is making progress in Gaza. It’s pretty obvious this deal was NOT pushed by Israel. I mean, seriously? “We’re going to leave, and rebuild, and hug every Palestinian”. Please, this is Biden trying to save face to boost his numbers in the election.
I will guarantee what will happen “We tried and gave Hamas everything they wanted, and they turned us down. We blame Palestinians for the collapse of this agreement”.
Netanyahu let October 7 happen as a pre-text to invade Gaza. You think he’s going to let this “good thing” pass? Israel won’t be happy until all Palestinians are dead or in another country.
Which phase has rebuild Gaza?
Biden is a special liar.
Biden… worst POTUS ever
This is a speech only, this is just a joke, nothing will happen, elections to distract the citizens
1. In phase 2, Biden mentioned again, the evacuation of IDF’s military.
2. What about the US restart of UNRWA funding.
Hiw can it be a genocide when hamas wanted it
So like God biden decides when people should die or live?
Finally. President Hoosters Hittup talks smack about Jen O’Side. Commentary by Nofuks Givven.
Is that history or political conversation🙃?
Exactly, the Israeli
Forces have made Gaza largely uninhabitable, and proposed that they themselves would withdraw from inhabited areas. It’s no deal
Biden makes a propaganda speech, on a ceasefire plan that has not been accepted. It is cruel put something out and get people’s hopes up, when, given the number of past failures, it is unlikely to succeed. And Biden doesn’t need a “plan.” All he needs to do is stop money and weapons going to Israel, which he has repeatedly been unwilling to do. In spite of saying that he would do just that if Israel went into Rafah. Israel crossed his “red line,” murdering scores of Palestinians and he did and said NOTHING. Or he could have just stopped vetoing every UN resolution calling for a ceasefire. Biden’s actions not his words, show exactly who he is.
The U.S. should stand down. We’re either complete failures or we’re stealing land 🤷♀️
Probably both
LOL, the IDF have just about wiped out Hamas and now the last few standing are trapped in small areas about to be eliminated yet Hamas still think they have the upper hand in negotiating a truce!
For those that arent bright enough to notice. Th 3 phase Dela biden has proposed is extremely similar to one proposed by Hamas in October and November. So who is really holding up the negotiations??
So Biden announced a war strategy change for Israel, but Netanyahu says no to the Israeli proposal? am I missing something?
UN and USA same. So boycott UN and USA
What is ip their sleeve now? We’ve seen this movue from Biden before. All this posturing for his upcoming election now polls show Trump is 6 % up since his conviction? Is sad America have these 2 running for president, pathetic indeed!
What agreement, what negotiation? Israel have destroyed everything in Gaza!!
There are no positive noises coming from Israel. There is no basis for that statement. Netanyahu has said he won’t stop until Hamas is destroyed which makes little sense in the context of a ceasefire.
That is a contradiction it’s true, but Hamas holds the hostages. There is talk that more than one has had her rapists’ baby and has been forcibly married. Perhaps there is a contradiction there too, in negotiating with the worst criminals in the human species?
Headline US and isreal no Hamas media is cowards call out everyone but Hamas bias
From the river to the sea
Biden finally told Israel the tap was being turned off. Of course they won’t admit that, it’s Israel’s ‘idea’. This mirrors closely with the last deal which Israel rejected. Still not good enough, It just calls for the return of Oct 6th
Netanyaho will never end this WAR until…..
No mention of the Palestinians or recognition of them self governing
“If I were an Arab leader, I would never sign an agreement with Israel. It is normal; we have taken their country. It is true God promised it to us, but how could that interest them? Our God is not theirs. There has been Anti-Semitism, the Nazis, Hitler, Auschwitz, but was that their fault? They see but one thing: we have come and we have stolen their country. Why would they accept that?”
David Ben-Gurion (the first Israeli Prime Minister)
It was a high stakes gamble for Biden to present this idea as having come from Israel. If everyone winds up agreeing to it, most people will forget that he stretched the truth to get the job done. But if not, how do we take the American president seriously?
No military solution
Hamas just keeps on writing checks that its civilian casualties’ bodies can’t cash.
US election propaganda!
Another drama by USA and Israel. They talks everything in backdoor and showing drama in front of cameras. Everybody knows America backs Israel politicaly, military. But they want to show America is a good guy and Israel doing this against USA will. I don’t know when Arab world mature enough to understand
Biden speaks with forked tongue
Biden is desperate to win US elections. Netahanyu dont want elections in Israel and wants to continue running the country under the war cabinet. Hundreds of IDF soldiers are dying or becoming permanently disabled. Hamas is winning the war. Iran is becomig more powerful now, as the Axis of Resistance has more firepower now with support from North Korea and Russia. US foregin policy is dead. US economy is in a mess. All these events are a result of Netahanyu’s personal war to stay in power to avoid his corruption charges. Thanks to Netahanyu and Biden for indirectly helping the destruction of Israel from the world map.
Joe Biden vote scheming, it means nothing remember he sends the weapons .don’t believe a word!
Israel will not agree to any truce until Hamas no longer exists.
Genocide ?
VERY SURPRISING!! LOL!!
How can you negotiate a ceasefire agreement between 2 parties when one of the 2 parties insists that a ceasefire cannot occur until the other party is utterly destroyed?
This deal is not good for Netanyahu at all. If it goes through then we will witness the end of Netanyahu political carrier. So the war must continue to keep him in power. Netanyahu has ready taste the weakness of Biden, so that is the fact. I hope the international community stopped the killing of innocent civilians in Gaza 😊
Truce and cease fire? 😂😂😂😂😂😂 Ya, right. Biden is jist appeasing the Islamic vote. With his other hand he supplies Israel with money and weapons. If this media outlet thinks we are stupid they are very mistaken. The Islamic cuase of terror is screwed.
“Chief partner with Izrell in this geno cide against Palestinians”… WELL SAID.
Any proposal that does not include complete and permanent liberation for all Palestinians – and for the rebuilding of their land – is NOT a just deal.
Biden’s peace proposal was another PR stunt for his Admin, just like the floating pier was. His poll numbers in the swing states are crashing, so this peace proposal, sold as from Israel, really sounded more like his Admin’s proposal. Why would he beg Israel to accept their own proposal?
The ceasefire proposal by Biden needs to be gone over with a fine toothcomb.with the best lawyers in the world. Palestine needs to have their own state and needs to be added in the proposal. Israel will look for lots of loopholes to continue the war after ceasefire.
Thank you so much Al Jazeera correspondent for the great analysis. ❤❤❤❤❤
Isrel must free all the Palestinian hostages and return all the land it took since 1948 and pay reparations to the Palestinians and pay back all the money it ever got from the US!
❤missing. U
Brandon’s “plan” for “peace” at best involves a return to the status quo with no real change to the fate of the Palestinians except for the part where they stopped getting bombed and instead get to live under occupation again.
prisoners vs captives ???!!!
I don’t think you can make a truce with satan.
No trust as long as occupation continues.
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
This proposal of deal is just in favour of Israel or world got failed to stop killing of innocent people
Telefono politico diablo.yamenlo
One day the Jews will be judged, inshallah
Why are we still looking towards U.S anything to help the Palestinian, everything is going according to their plans. Start looking elsewhere.
The Palestinians should take the generous deal and be grateful
Israel is always above the law, no one can prosecute them, the US always vetoes it
Free free Palestine
Is anyone actually surprised by this?
High level Hippocracy they are on sarail and america .